The Journal
Fashion · Economics · Sustainability

Sustainability

Fashion's overproduction problem — and the case for buying surplus

Editorial desk · Reading time: 5 min

The clothing industry has a habit few people see: it makes far more than it can sell. Overproduction is baked into how fashion works — and understanding it reframes surplus stock not as a bargain-bin afterthought, but as one of the more sensible ways to shop.

Why brands make too much

Manufacturing at scale rewards big orders. Producing a little more per style lowers the cost per unit, protects against sell-outs, and hits minimum factory quantities. Multiply those incentives across a global catalogue refreshed every few weeks and you get structural surplus: perfectly good garments produced in numbers that demand was never going to match.

Where the excess goes

Unsold stock has to go somewhere. Historically some was stored, marked down, or in the worst cases written off. Increasingly, brands route it into liquidation and off-price channels, where it can be sold in volume and actually worn. That's the better outcome — for the buyer, for the brand's balance sheet, and for the resources already spent making the item.

Buying surplus doesn't create demand for more production. It puts to use what has already been made.

The environmental maths

Every garment carries an embedded cost: the water, energy, fibre and labour used to produce it. That cost is spent the moment the item is made, whether or not anyone ever wears it. Clothing that moves through surplus channels and onto a real person recovers some of that investment. Clothing that sits in a warehouse or is discarded recovers none of it.

Why it's cheaper — and still good

Surplus is inexpensive because the expensive parts of retail have been removed: the flagship store, the marketing campaign, the full-price shelf life. What remains is the same brand-new, tagged product. Lower price here reflects a leaner path to your wardrobe, not lower quality.

A more thoughtful way to shop

None of this asks anyone to buy more than they need — the opposite. It simply suggests that when you do buy, choosing from what already exists is a quietly rational choice. Surplus shopping turns an industry inefficiency into something useful, and that's a good thing to understand before your next purchase.

General information about the fashion industry and retail supply chains. Figures and practices described are broadly reported industry norms and provided for context only.